Bank of Canada would be ‘justified’ cutting rates by half a point. Here’s why – National
After proceeding at a tentative, 25-basis-point cut pace in the first three interest rate cuts of its cycle, many economists expect the Bank of Canada will take an oversized step lower in its upcoming decision on Wednesday.
The central bank’s policy rate stands at 4.25 per cent following the most recent quarter-point cut in early September.
But a lot’s changed in Canada’s economy since that time.
For one, inflation’s looking to be well-tamed, dropping from a bull’s eye on the Bank of Canada’s two per cent target to 1.6 per cent in the latest reading.
Tiff Macklem, governor of the central bank, has made clear in recent speeches that the Bank of Canada is equally concerned about inflation dropping too low below two per cent as it is about price pressures holding too high.
While Macklem had previously warned there could be “bumps” on the path back to the price stability target, inflation has come under control faster than the central bank first anticipated. Previous forecasts called for a return to two per cent inflation sometime in 2025.
Randall Bartlett, senior director of Canadian economics at Desjardins, tells Global News that he doesn’t see much further room for inflation to fall in the months ahead, with September’s sharp drop in gas prices unlikely to be repeated.
50 basis points… or more?
But Bartlett adds that the rest of the country’s economic output is also coming in weaker than the Bank of Canada expected.
The central bank’s most recent projections from July had real gross domestic product rebounding to 2.8 per cent in the third quarter of the year; actual results are tracking closer to 1.5 per cent, according to Desjardins’ analysis.
And outside of solid job gains in the most recent report for September, Canada’s labour market has also shown cracks through the summer, with the unemployment rate rising briefly to a seven-year high outside the pandemic.
Get weekly money news
Get expert insights, Q&A on markets, housing, inflation, and personal finance information delivered to you every Saturday.
“The unemployment rate is still pretty elevated and the trend is not the Bank’s friend. It seems to be moving gradually higher over time, despite some wiggles,” Bartlett says.
Hopes for any rapid improvement in the economic outlook have also been soured by the Bank of Canada’s own quarterly surveys tracking consumer and business sentiment, both of which showed little sign of a return to spending on the horizon.
“We think all of this adds together … to suggest that a 50-basis-point rate cut is probably in the cards next week,” Bartlett says.
Such a scenario would mark the first time in more than 15 years that the Bank of Canada cut its policy rate by 50 basis points, outside the pandemic years.
Desjardins was among early forecasters calling for a half-point cut in October, but they’re far from the only ones.
Economists from big banks including Scotiabank, RBC, CIBC and BMO have pencilled in an oversized step this week. TD Bank’s senior economist James Orlando acknowledged the growing case for a half-point cut in a note to clients, but argued that signs of resilience elsewhere in the labour market warrant another quarter-point move from the central bank.
As of Friday, Reuters said currency swap markets were pricing in an over 76 per cent chance of a 50-basis-point cut and another 25-basis-point reduction in December.
CIBC chief economist Avery Shenfeld even upped the ante in a note to clients last Friday.
While he maintained CIBC’s call is for a 50-basis-point drop on Wednesday, he argued that a 75-basis-point “mega-move” could be on the table as well.
With the belief that there will be at least 75 basis points of easing in the policy rate between now and the end of the year, Shenfeld argued the Bank of Canada may frontload its cuts to get ahead of the curve.
There’s precedence for such movements, he noted, harkening back to the central bank’s 100-basis-point hike back in July 2022, when monetary policymakers were rapidly tightening to get decades-high inflation back under control.
The U.S. looms large over the rate path
Movements in the United States could be what pushes the Bank of Canada to stick to 50 basis points, however, Shenfeld said in counter to his own argument.
The U.S. Federal Reserve kicked off its easing cycle in September with an oversized half-point cut of its own. Macklem has maintained that the governing council sets its policy rate based on conditions north of the border, though too wide a gap in rates between the Bank of Canada and the Fed can hurt the Canadian dollar’s exchange rate, potentially exacerbating inflation on U.S. imports.
Bartlett notes that while the Bank of Canada is “justified” in cutting by half a percentage point based on domestic factors, the Fed’s big step and further cuts from other central banks around the world do “open the door” for Macklem and his compatriots to follow suit.
But recent strong economic data from the U.S. has scaled back expectations about the pace of easing from the Fed, Shenfeld noted. If the Bank of Canada is looking to avoid spooking financial markets with a larger, 75-basis-point move, it could keep to the already priced-in 50 basis points, he said.
It’s not just the Fed’s easing cycle that will have the Bank of Canada looking south of the border in the months ahead.
The outcome of the U.S. presidential election will weigh heavily on the Canadian economy, and by extension, the Bank of Canada’s rate path, Bartlett says.
A Desjardins analysis from earlier this month anticipates a sharper decline in economic activity for both Canada and the U.S. in the event of a second Donald Trump presidency, rather than a Kamala Harris victory. Trump has threatened to levy blanket tariffs on imports to the U.S., a move that would depress Canada’s hopes for an economic rebound and could trigger a recession in the worst-case scenario.
“The Bank of Canada will need to bring that in, both in terms of what the tariff impacts are going to be in the Canadian economy, but also weaker overall U.S. economic activity … and what the spillovers are to the Canadian economy,” Bartlett says.
While such a move could hasten the Bank of Canada’s rate cuts in a bid to gird the economy, Bartlett notes it could be some time before the policies from a possible second Trump term filter through to the central bank’s outlook.
The Bank of Canada would adjust its forecasts when specific policies are announced, he says, and are therefore unlikely to be factored in until the April monetary policy report — a few months into the new president’s tenure.
For the Bank of Canada’s final rate decision of the year in December, Bartlett argues the debate will likely be between 25 and 50 basis points once more, where more “sluggish” economic activity in the months ahead would point to the need for a steeper cut.
— with files from Reuters
